The Underclassmen’s Race to College

Andover High School’s AP restrictions called into question by students, graduates

Avery Slaughter || STAFF WRITER

By the time the Class of 2028 first stepped foot in the lobby of Andover High School, it was abundantly clear that Advanced Placement courses were going to be off-limits for a while. During the student orientations that had occurred in the months previous, they had been told they weren’t ready for classes of such rigor; they weren’t mature enough and would have to wait until they were juniors to handle a responsibility so vast.

The rule barring APs seems innocent, but for some freshmen and sophomores, it is a cause of great stress. “After high school” is a concept that hopeful college prospects begin to consider as early as elementary school, and the inability to maximize APs as soon as ninth grade can be concerning with that in mind. That being said, the reasoning and logic behind the restriction is sound—how could underclassmen manage the workload and intensity of college classes, given the well-known academic difficulty of APs? Despite the good intentions, is it possible the act of minimizing that stress inadvertently causes more?

It’s important to note that two new APs are being introduced in the fall of 2025. These two courses include AP Seminar, open exclusively to sophomores, and AP Government, open to grades 10-12 (see sidebar for more details). AP US History and AP Java Programming was also made available to sophomores this year. These four courses are the only APs typically offered before junior year, though infrequent exceptions are made for students who demonstrate advanced proficiency in math and/or computer science.

For Shauna Murray, the question about APs is a loaded one. Working as both a high school teacher in New Hampshire and a School Committee member in Andover Public Schools, she’s deeply involved in the lives of students. Murray noted that the rules regarding APs and general course restrictions are not decided by the School Committee and are instead up to the discretion of the guidance department. The College Board also does not have a say in how the classes are run in individual schools beyond the administration of the AP exams. (Multiple attempts to reach Aixa de Kelley, coordinator of the guidance department, by email were unsuccessful.)

“I think there are some kids that are ready, but it’s really a student-by-student basis,” Murray said. “It’s tricky because you know the requirements are there for a reason, but maybe it could be a little bit more flexible.”

Current AHS students have varying opinions. Sophomore Connor McGovern expressed frustration with the policy and its possible implications on his future. He worried that his college chances were slimmer compared to future graduates of other schools with more lax restrictions and that ultimately it would damage his experience after high school.

“I think [the rule] probably does [hurt my chances],” McGovern said, “and you could also shorten the amount of years you have to take in college if you take a lot of APs in high school. I think about that.”

Canyu Li, who has eight APs under her belt as a senior, had an opposing view. She wondered if the stress she would have felt as an underclassman would have been insurmountable had she had the option to take APs, though she acknowledged that, when she was younger, she did wish to take them. Ultimately, she thought that the downside to taking these courses early on tends to outweigh the benefits, especially with college admittance in mind. She explained that, in her experience, colleges often compared you to other students in your school to ensure fair consideration in the admission process.

Many people were inclined to agree with that assessment, though former college admissions officer Jayne Jones suggested it was a bit more complicated.

“It all depends,” said Jones, now an AHS guidance counselor. “It depends upon the student, the college, and many other factors that make up a decision for admissions. Some more selective colleges want to see several AP classes, and less selective colleges may want to see a few APs, and still other colleges may be fine without any APs.”

While the freshmen at AHS were acclimating to the environment of the school this past fall, Diya Ganesh exited the bus she took from her lab at Northeastern University to her dorm. Having graduated from AHS in 2023, she had recent experience with how the AP restriction impacted her college experience. She took six APs herself, and she recognized that she was at a disadvantage in terms of college credits compared to her classmates, who had AP counts ranging from eight to twelve.

Jordan Altaffer, 2017 graduate of AHS and family friend of Ganesh, agreed at that moment. Though he had recently concluded his time at Georgia Tech, the toll his shortage of AP credit hours had taken was still present in his life. In addition to an increased amount of time filling his degree course requirements, taking more courses was financially inconvenient.

“If I had been able to take more [APs], I could’ve skipped my [college] freshman English classes and my freshman history,” Altaffer said. Not taking those courses would have both cut an entire semester from his college experience and minimized the cost of his classes.

Ganesh had similar sentiments. “People that are graduating sooner tend to get a higher priority in picking classes. […] I cannot emphasize how helpful having those credit hours ahead of time are,” she said.

The question of whether or not freshmen and sophomores should be able to take APs brings to light what Murray considered a larger social problem. How can high school students possibly have enough time in their lives to balance such hefty course loads and their own personal health? According to her, the “race to college” represents the flawed values in our society. Instead of prioritizing the well-being of students during the transition to adulthood and independence, we drive students to overwhelm themselves with academics to fulfill arbitrary requirements for further education.

“One of the things that is happening in society is that we’re pushing kids way too hard,” Murray said. “It’s just this vicious cycle of wanting to do more and wanting to achieve more.”

Related Posts

New Faculty, Staff Join AHS
  • November 13, 2026

Alexa Anasopoulos, Special Education Teacher

Alexa Anasopoulos, a new special education teacher in geometry and algebra classes, worked as a substitute teacher while majoring in business, and that is when she realized that she wanted to teach.

When subbing, Anasopoulos enjoyed connecting with students. After finishing her major and working for a few years in business, she realized that this was not what she really wanted to do. So she went back to get a degree for education.

“I just loved being able to build relationships with students and help support them in their academic journeys,” said Anasopoulos. “I went and got my master’s and became an educator, and I still love what I do 14 years later.” — By Zaynah Sheikh

Siobhan Curran, Science Teacher

Siobhan Curran,  a new teacher within the science department, has found creative ways to bring her love of  art into her curriculum.

Outside of the classroom,  Curran enjoys painting. She began painting in high school and has since continued, making art pieces for family and friends while also pursuing it purely for enjoyment.

Curran doesn’t only limit her love of art to her personal life, though. She incorporated art into assignments at her previous school. “I had a bunch of kids who were interested in art and also chemistry,” said Curran, “ and so some of them came up with really cool labs where they’d be looking at making paint or analyzing copper printing-related techniques.”

Inspiring her students to think creatively is one of the main reasons Curran enjoys teaching. Her guiding philosophy? “I think it’s important to realize that kids can do more than everybody always gives them credit for,” she said. — By Stephanie Okeyo

Yiqi ‘Amy’ Guo, Science Teacher

Yiqi ‘Amy’ Guo, a new teacher in AHS’s science department, shares her passions for curiosity, enrichment, and growth with her students.

Amy Guo teaches both biology and forensic science. A major part of her personal teaching philosophy is to be open to all levels of learning, and to make sure that all of her students retain a drive to reach their maximum potential.

“What I really want is for everyone to feel like they learned something with me and their peers by the end of the year,” Guo said. “I want them to feel like the skills they developed in class can be applied to solve problems in the future. Maybe not just for science, it could be for something bigger or something we don’t know yet.” — By Garrett Berube

Melissa Jacobo, Social Worker

Melissa Jacobo, a new social worker at AHS who has many years of experience working at Doherty Middle School and, prior to that, Massachusetts General Hospital, pursued her profession after working for a federally funded grant program.

Student Support Services, funded by the U.S. Department of Education, provides aid to students struggling financially, academically, or personally. With the program, Jacobo worked with first generation, low income, and disabled students, and it was also where she discovered she wanted to be a social worker.

“I remember being like, ‘This is magic,’” Jacobo said when relaying her experience working with Student Support Services.

Jacobo’s favorite part of her new position is working with students. When asked if there was anything she would change, Jacobo said, “I have no idea yet.” — By Madeleine Carlson

Rhiannon Jones, Science Teacher

New science teacher Rhiannon Jones was inspired when she was a high school student, and now enjoys helping her own students excel in both science and dance.

Beyond AHS, Jones teaches different styles of dance to children between 2 and 18 in her hometown. Here at AHS, human anatomy is her focus.

Before Jones became a teacher, she grew up in a family that was very involved in science. And then she was inspired by one teacher in particular: her freshman science teacher.

“The way she approached teaching with a passion for the subject, and her positive attitude towards students and their learning made me want to be part of the teaching community,” Jones said. — By the ANDOVERVIEW staff, with reporting by correspondent Elena Thatcher

Lisa Kinley, Instructional Aide

Lisa Kinley transitioned into her role as an instructional aide at Andover High School this year to support students in the classroom, building on a career path that began with teaching art.

Kinley, who holds degrees in fine art and art education, taught art to elementary, middle, and high school students in Ohio, California, and Oregon before coming to Andover. Although she did not always plan to pursue teaching, she discovered she enjoyed helping others understand subjects she knew well. After taking time away from teaching to raise her family, she decided it was time to work in a school setting again. Looking ahead, she is considering returning to the classroom as an art teacher, while continuing to explore her interests outside of school.

“I think the most rewarding part about teaching is getting a glimpse into the students’ lives as you watch them grow and progress,” Kinley said. “You start to develop a relationship with them and learn what their interests are and what they enjoy doing.” — By Andrew Boles

Elisa Sanders, Special Education Teacher

Elisa Sanders, a new faculty member at AHS, now works in special education after leaving the business world.

Sanders originally earned her undergraduate degree in business administration, but went back to school at 40 to get her master’s degree in special education after she realized she disliked the business world. What also encouraged her to make this transition is her younger brother, who has multiple disabilities. When Sanders and her brother grew up in the 1970s, he didn’t have the same opportunities and programs accessible to him that are offered to kids today.

“He’s kind of my motivation,” said Sanders. “I feel like he could have had a different life if there were more opportunities available to him.”

It is Sander’s 19th year teaching, and she teaches special education in English as well as specialized reading, and co-teaches an American Voices class here at AHS. She just loves being able to help out with kids who have similar struggles to her brother’s and is glad to give them the chances he was unable to have 50 years ago. — By Neha Kalagarla

John Tigani, World Languages Teacher

John Tigani, Andover High’s new Latin I & IV teacher, travels boundlessly in the search for knowledge.

Tigani was raised in Wilmington, Del., but attended school in Massachusetts. Most people would choose to go to college close to their home and family. Tigani is not like most people. He traveled across the country, studying history in Berkeley, Calif. But his love for his the Bay State never truly eroded, as he later returned to Massachusetts to teach Latin, driven by his passion for history (especially the Roman Republic) and his desire to prepare students for the world after high school. Lucky for him, Andover’s Latin program gave him leeway to do both.

“In no other job,” Tigani said, “do you get to prepare your students for life after school under the lens of the subject that you love.”— By Maaz Mirza

Tyler Walles, Interim Assistant Athletic Director

AHS’s interim assistant athletic director and new boys hockey coach, Tyler Walles, is looking forward to giving back to the Andover community through his new position.

Sports have remained a constant in Walles’ life. Growing up immersed in the athletics of the AHS community, Walles has always felt a strong connection to the sports program. This passion bloomed, from playing baseball and hockey at Andover High School to recently graduating from Sacred Heart University with a degree in sports management.

“My life’s always revolved around sports. It’s kind of what I know best,” Walles said. “It was kind of a no-brainer when this opportunity [at AHS] came up.”

As an alumnus, he feels especially connected to the culture that Andover provides: “Growing up in this town, it’s what I’ve known and what I love. Andover made me who I am today and I think it’s important to get back to this community.” — By Hannah Armstrong

Jiang Xiaohan, Science Teacher

Jiang Xiaohan might be a new science teacher at AHS, but she has a lifetime of experience teaching and has always loved helping people learn.

Teaching isn’t just a job for Xiaohan; it is a lifelong passion and way for her to connect with her family. Beginning with her grandparents, the practice was passed down to her parents and it felt natural for her to teach as well. While other kids played games of tag, Xiaohan chose peaceful evenings with her family.

“Growing up,” Xiaohan explained, “I was helping my parents with grading their students’ work, and I enjoyed doing that.”

Every summer, Xiaohan returns to China, where her parents are still working hard teaching, to reconnect and get the occasional tip. — By Dylan Czepiel

Continue reading
Comfort Dog Officer Maggie Sadly Passes
  • November 13, 2026

By Anya Gorovits || EDITOR IN CHIEF

AHS’s beloved Officer Maggie unfortunately died on Sunday, November 8th following a brief illness.

Maggie was a four year old Australian cobberdog. She belonged to the town of Andover, but outside of school, she lived with School Resource Officer Thomas Paolera.

Paolera spent many months training and preparing Maggie before she joined AHS in early 2024. Paolera taught her general obedience and basic commands and also consulted also with the trainer of Rex, Andover’s other trained dog, to ensure Maggie was fully prepared to be in a school environment. In school, the comfort dog was always by Paolera’s side, joining him in the lobby before classes and in the cafeteria during lunch.

Officer Maggie had no patrol dog duties, rather acting as a support system for students. Many loved visiting her corner of Paolera’s office or coming up to pet her in the hallways. As stated by Superintendent Keith Taverna, Maggie “touched the lives of countless students.”

Maggie had her own Instagram account, which features adorable photos and funny bloopers of her life. Last year, Paolera wrote a children’s book about his canine companion; AHS alumni Olivia Horwath illustrated the book. Maggie is also currently featured on the Andover Police Department’s scarecrow downtown.

Maggie will be deeply missed by the Andover community. The AHS counseling team is available to any students seeking support following this loss.

Continue reading

Leave a Reply

You Might Also Like

Spanish Department to Host Day of the Dead Fair

  • November 12, 2025

Funding the Future of Science: Proposed NIH Funding Cuts Throw US Biomedical Research Into Uncertainty

  • November 4, 2025
Funding the Future of Science: Proposed NIH Funding Cuts Throw US Biomedical Research Into Uncertainty

Student-Hosted Video Game Hackathon Scheduled for Late September

  • September 22, 2025
Student-Hosted Video Game Hackathon Scheduled for Late September

AHS Student Directs Coming-of-Age Film, ‘Horizon’

  • June 9, 2025

World Languages Coordinator Reflects On Career, Retirement

  • June 9, 2025
World Languages Coordinator Reflects On Career, Retirement

CollegeBoard Scores 1/5 on AP Testing Administration

  • June 9, 2025