Sports vs Arts: Superior or Similar?

By Sonja Kruecker Green

GUEST COLUMNIST

Full disclosure– I am not the keenest participant of team sports. 

But don’t get me wrong. That doesn’t mean I don’t highly value physical activity and sports. I love to hike, swim, bike, and I play a mean game of badminton. I love watching soccer and I have been even known to watch the occasional football game, eliciting groans from certain family members. What I don’t understand about American culture, however, is why sports are elevated to the level that they are. It seems to be a national obsession. If I were to say “who’s Tom Brady?” can you imagine how jaws would drop? But if I were to talk about the violinist, Hilary Hahn, I would get unabashed, blank stares. 

Starting at an early age, children in America have been taught the value of athletics. Young kids are expected to choose their team sport, and from that moment on, they are encouraged to practice, compete, and rise to the top. Yet, this same sort of energy does not seem to apply to the arts. I mean, how many times have you heard “what is your sport”? I have heard it a lot. However, I have never heard “what is your performing art”? Why is this? The implication is that everyone should have a sport, but having a performing art seems completely optional. Why else would PE be a requirement every year but not the fine arts, much less the performing arts? 

I will reiterate that I do, in fact, value sports. In addition to providing an outlet for physical activity and entertainment, sports teach their players important lessons in teamwork, leadership, perseverance and resilience. What many may not fully appreciate, however, is that the performing arts can teach these same important life skills and lessons. In fact, leadership, teamwork, practice, persistence, and resilience are all vital in the performing arts. 

Both musicians and athletes alike understand that in order to improve, one must practice. And practice. And then practice some more. As a violinist, rigorous practice must happen regularly. Training my fingers daily is key to learning the notes for a piece, whether it is a chord where the intonation needs work or a tricky rhythm that is just not intuitive. It may not always be fun, but it is what must be done to make progress. The reward will never come instantly. I will admit- when I was much younger, I did not have the best practice habits; it was never very focused practicing and I easily became distracted because– lets’ face it– practice can be monotonous. However, just like for athletes, the perseverance eventually pays off. I have learned how to improve my practicing and appreciate the value of persistence even when it is tiresome, a skill that is essential in so many aspects of life. 

Just as sports do, the performing arts also build character. Playing the violin has helped me to place myself outside of my comfort zone. I can still remember my 7-year-old self, absolutely terrified to walk on stage for my first violin recital. I did not like the idea of being watched or heard by so many people. But every time I have performed on stage since, it has gotten a little bit easier. I have learned ways to deal with the anxiety and I have become more resilient. I think this is also an important life skill that is also said to be honed when doing competitive sports. 

So what about leadership or teamwork? You cannot learn those skills through the performing arts, can you? Well sure you can! 

When I play in an orchestra I am a team player. In a large ensemble like this, teamwork and leadership are vital for the music to come together in the end. I’m responsible for knowing my part, but the whole is so much greater than the sum of its parts. Not only must I learn my part to fit in with my section of the orchestra, but within my section, we must collaborate with each other. And not only must our own section collaborate, but the many sections within the orchestra must all work together as well. We must listen to each other in order to understand how our parts come together seamlessly. Teamwork and some leadership are crucial. In my chamber ensembles, these skills became even more necessary. There is no conductor to help keep the musicians together. Every player is responsible for their own single part, but must also listen very keenly, must respond to, and lead the other musicians. We must give cues and take cues. It is a cooperative effort. If, for example, the violist and second violinist are not listening to the cellist for the tempo, or the first violinist does not give the proper cue, the music will immediately derail. We are all pieces of a puzzle that fit together, and through teamwork, leadership (and practice, of course) that puzzle can eventually be assembled to produce something great. 

The next time you watch a theater production, or a show choir performance, or an orchestra concert, I hope you will appreciate that athletes and fine arts performers are not so very different.

Related Posts

Capstone Pass System Carries On
  • May 7, 2026

JANAESA MACASAET || ARTS EDITOR

Principal Jimmy D’Andrea has confirmed that passes that allow Capstone students to leave campus for research purposes will remain for the next year, denying rumors that they would be completely eliminated. 

Seniors in the Capstone Research class spend the year answering a question through both qualitative and quantitative methods. These passes allow students to leave campus for primary research. They may interview professionals, complete case studies, run experiments, or utilize outside resources such as Memorial Hall Library using these passes. 

Entering the school year, the status of the passes were initially unclear, concerning a number of students. 

“Multiple students have met with me because there were rumors circulating that I wanted to get rid of the CAPS passes, which was not accurate,” said D’Andrea. “I just want to make sure that we knew if a student was leaving, and then making sure that they were getting back.”

According to Capstone teacher Rebecca D’Alise, the passes were under review at the start of the year as school administration and staff worked through logistics. 

“The status at the beginning of the year was ‘To Be Determined,’” said D’Alise. “As a CAPS team, we were asked to work with administrators to make sure that there were strong protocols put into place to make sure that students [were] able to utilize this unique experience while also adhering to school expectations and safety requirements.”

Senior Kari Belson explained that at the start of the year, many students believed they would not have access to the Capstone passes at all. Belson’s project is focused on menstrual health education in elementary schools, which is greatly eased by the passes. 

“For some people, it was an issue to not have those Capstone passes,” Belson said. “A lot of research, especially observational studies, can only happen during the school day.”

After deliberation, passes were later made available, but the delay made it challenging for students such as herself, whose topic is focused on elementary schools, to start their primary research. “It was really important for me to have that opportunity,” she said. 

Other students echoed the idea that Capstone passes are essential. Senior Claire Woodring emphasized that these projects benefit from real-world interaction that cannot be done inside the classroom.  

“If a student can’t continue their research until they do an interview, or something similar that can’t happen in the school building, arguably more time is wasted by Caps students not doing anything in class because they can’t make any progress on their work in the classroom,” Woodring said. 

Woodring added that while misuse may occur, the removal of passes would limit opportunities for meaningful research. “I think it’s important to keep in mind that this is a senior-only class,” Woodring said. “The people taking it are, or are about to be, adults, who are going to have to be responsible for themselves, and a special privilege like the Caps Pass is an opportunity to work on that.”

The passes remain available, with a few changes made to the system. The process to request a pass has not changed—students and teachers have their own personal conversations if there is a need for a pass, often requiring the student to be in good academic standing in the class. 

Otherwise, passes can now only be used during long blocks or last blocks to ensure that students come back to school on time; students must ensure that their interviews are held within safe locations; students must retrieve all of their items before signing out to leave. 

“We just want to make sure that we know where students are and that they’re getting back to school,” D’Andrea said.

D’Alise mentioned that another significant change involves the use of Memorial Hall Library during the secondary research phase. Previously, students were able to use the library for both primary and secondary research—now, passes can only be used for primary research, such as observations and interviews. 

D’Andrea emphasized that the review process was for the system to be improved and for students’ safety to be maintained. 

“I think the program has always been great. I had some questions about the process for the passes, and I think the collaboration with the teachers has been really positive,” said D’Andrea. “I’m a big supporter of the program because I think it’s great to give students an opportunity to do deep research in something that they’re interested in.” 

D’Alise emphasized that the pass system enriches the Capstone course and has lifelong benefits. 

“I would be extremely disappointed to see the [Capstone] pass eliminated from this class as it presents students with the opportunity to develop a number of skill sets beyond primary research, such as maturity, accountability, and responsibility,” D’Alise said. “These are skills that students will need as they leave AHS.”

Continue reading
SATIRE: The College Board, a Humble Hero
  • May 7, 2026

AREETA FAIZ || SOCIAL MEDIA EDITOR

In an era where billion-dollar corporations are being constantly scrutinized for their neverending greed, it can be hard to overlook the admirable and productive gifts they actually bring to the table. The College Board demonstrates through its charitable actions what it truly means to be a not-for-profit company in America (not to be confused with a nonprofit). Loved or loathed, it bestows upon us something you can’t put a price on: opportunity. And it makes sure that each and every one of us is able to enjoy it.

Cynics may point out that the College Board makes over a billion dollars annually through AP exams, SAT registrations, and score reports. That being said, it’s important to remember that they are, at their core, not-for-profit, meaning that they aim to never prioritize revenue over students. 

Take Advanced Placement (AP) courses, for example. For just $99, high schoolers receive the invaluable opportunity to demonstrate college-level rigor on a 1-5 scale, given they have the resources, teachers, funding, and capacity to do so. Of course, this only saves you more money in college: a similar, notoriously equitable system that keeps everyone’s well-being in mind.

Or perhaps take the SAT. For just $68, plus a modest fee, or some additional modest fees, students are given the privilege to demonstrate their academic excellence in just two hours. Universally beloved, one simple standardized test on a Saturday morning allows anyone to easily take one big step towards their BigFuture! 

Students who feel pressured to invest in College Board’s services should remember that universities only suggest, strongly encourage, or require the submission of students’ SAT scores. If an individual feels uninclined to take part, they are by no means at a disadvantage—opting out just means everyone else just gets to be at an advantage. And the best part is, there is no other option. That’s far from a monopoly.

Critics wrongfully accuse the College Board of enjoying the benefits of a nonprofit organization while accumulating vast excesses of wealth. However, they fail to see the bigger picture: where else should this money go but the pockets of CEO David Coleman? While $1.6 billion may seem like a lot of money, your future is priceless, and tax exemption is a corporate right.

Remarkably, the College Board has stayed true to its mission of college-readiness since its famously humble beginnings in 1899. Since 2019, they’ve graciously offered $23 million in scholarships to low-income students, a whopping 1.4 percent of their annual revenue. 

Through its extensive dedication to philanthropy, the College Board proves to reflect the true meaning of education: accessibility, equity, and opportunity, a sentiment that every American student should cherish.

Continue reading

Leave a Reply

You Might Also Like

Spanish Department to Host Day of the Dead Fair

  • November 12, 2025

Funding the Future of Science: Proposed NIH Funding Cuts Throw US Biomedical Research Into Uncertainty

  • November 4, 2025
Funding the Future of Science: Proposed NIH Funding Cuts Throw US Biomedical Research Into Uncertainty

Student-Hosted Video Game Hackathon Scheduled for Late September

  • September 22, 2025
Student-Hosted Video Game Hackathon Scheduled for Late September

World Languages Coordinator Reflects On Career, Retirement

  • June 9, 2025
World Languages Coordinator Reflects On Career, Retirement

CollegeBoard Scores 1/5 on AP Testing Administration

  • June 9, 2025

AHS Student Directs Coming-of-Age Film, ‘Horizon’

  • June 9, 2025

Discover more from AHS NEWSPAPER

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading