Counselor Switch Creates Confusion
By Maddox To || STAFF WRITER
Many students were assigned former guidance counselor Mellissa Todd, a long-standing counselor before she left in the early 2023 school year to work at a school closer to her home.
Shortly after, counselor Mary “Molly” Creamer replaced her and things were up and running again. But unfortunately, Creamer had to transfer schools at the end of the 2024 school year. After Creamer left, all of her students were dispersed among pre-existing counselors on the team here at Andover High.
“I feel good about it because they’re all nice people,” shared junior Smit Patel, describing all the counselors.
Junior, Razan Hawat also shared a relatively unbothered and positive stance on the situation: “For me, it hasn’t been too bothersome. Other than the fact that you [no longer] have the same connection to your new counselor as you had with your previous one, [the switch] overall hasn’t been too bad.”
Junior Nicole Flanigan shared the same sort of sentiment as Hawat, adding, “I do think it’s sort of annoying–having to go over everything all over again to a new person.”
As students’ opinions on the whole counselor-situation changes, some share a more frustrated reaction.
Junior Will Dugan, expressed discontent with the lack of continuity as counselor assignments change. “It’s annoying how this is the third guidance counselor that we’ve had in three years,” he said. “So as other people said, every year, we keep having to repeat our introductions, when really at this point, we should be—like a lot of our peers are—really comfortable with [our] guidance counselor.”
This sentiment is connected to the discontent students are feeling with the fact that they won’t have a counselor that really understands and has a grounded profile of them. A counselor having a good understanding of each student is crucial for college recs in the early bits of senior year.
For the first few weeks of school, junior Aneesa Hazarika was left with a problem that has persisted since Creamer’s departure from her position. “Any time I had a question, when [I] had Ms. Creamer, she never really had an answer,” Hazarika said. “She didn’t know how to do a lot of things, including my course selection meeting. She always had to leave the room or ask someone else.”
This dynamic between new counselor and student lengthened meeting times—which could have been solved with experience as a counselor. “It was hard to work with her, because she didn’t really know what we were doing,” which wasn’t her fault at all as she had only been a substitute counselor for a year. In Hazarika’s experience, having a completely different counselor this year extended her problem with her academic schedule since the 2024 spring semester.
Junior Milena Tiernan expressed sympathy for the new counselors assigned Creamer’s past pupils: “It’s not only really unsustainable for the students, but I think it’s also a large weight on the other counselors, because [it means] every single one has a higher workload now–having even more students in their counseling agenda.” Tiernan worries that this increase in workload for the rest of the counselors will water down the connections and profile-building between the counselors and their students.













