Former AHS Football Coach Drops Lawsuit Against Andover
Anya Gorovits || EDITOR IN CHIEF
Longtime Andover educator and former AHS football coach Ernest Perry recently dropped a lawsuit against the Town of Andover and AHS Principal James D’Andrea.
An AHS alum himself, Perry had been coaching football at AHS for 14 years at the time of the lawsuit. The issue commenced in November 2024, when AHS asked Perry to reapply to his coaching position. School administrators maintained that all coaches were required to reapply annually, though Perry alleged that he’d never been asked to do so before.
In the reapplication process, Perry was ultimately denied re-employment. In his place was hired Jason Fielding, a younger coach and previous defensive coordinator at Central Catholic. Claiming this decision to be unjust, Perry first issued a formal grievance to Andover’s school committee before issuing a Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination (MCAD) complaint and eventually filing a lawsuit.
Filed on August 14, 2026, Perry’s lawsuit included three counts: age discrimination, disability discrimination and retaliation. Perry is 61 years old and has a condition called dropped foot, which affects walking ability and qualifies as a disability under MA law, according to Perry’s complaint. Perry alleged that the hiring process treated him differently from younger and non-disabled coaches, and that his age and disability contributed to the decision not to rehire him. Additionally, Perry alleged that the decision to hire Fielding may have been predetermined. He cited a conversation in which he claimed a coach was told that Fielding would receive the position before Perry had even completed his interview.
According to Andover News and public trial documents, Andover denied Perry’s allegations in its response to the lawsuit, arguing that Perry had failed to meet the performance standards required for the position. The response, however, did not specify what those performance standards were. Andover’s response to the suit also disputed Perry’s claims that he had not previously been required to reapply and denied that the hiring decision had been predetermined. Andover Head of Communications Nicole Keiser declined to comment.
The case ultimately did not proceed to trial. On October 2, Perry announced that he had instructed his attorney to voluntarily dismiss the case. According to Perry, his primary goal in filing the lawsuit had been to regain his position as AHS football coach, and he had come to believe that this was no longer a realistic outcome.
In his statement announcing the dismissal, Perry praised Fielding as a “fantastic young coach” and said he believed the football program was in good hands. He also expressed respect for D’Andrea, former Athletic Director Wayne Puglisi and coach David Fazio. According to Andover News, Superintendent Keith Taverna similarly thanked Perry for his decades of service to Andover Public Schools and wished him well moving forward.











